Posted by: 1000fish | November 18, 2026

The Best Fishmas Ever

DATELINE: DECEMBER 22, 2025 – PATRICK’S POINT, CALIFORNIA

“My God,” I said to myself. “This is the same camping spot where I destroyed a relationship in 1982.” I reflected back 43 years to a much younger and even more inconsiderate version of myself, and it hit me that I probably didn’t ever apologize to Cindy.

I owe so many apologies to so many old girlfriends that delivering them individually would be impossible, but a few of my misdeeds stand out over most of the others. One of these dates back to a September 1982 camping trip to Patrick’s Point in Northern California. We got there hours late, missing the sunset, because I insisted on stopping “for five minutes” at Clear Lake. Once we finally got to the coast and set up camp, there were late night events that shan’t be repeated here but that were not my finest behavior around other humans or wildlife. (I realize the lack of detail is unsatisfying, but it’s truly for the best, especially for my younger readers. Thank goodness the ammo ran out and there were no sharp objects in easy reach.) It certainly marked the end of that particular relationship, and since I’m not a big camper, I had not been back to that area for over 40 years.

Back to the present day, you probably know that Christmas is a sacred time in the household that Marta and I have forged (together with our stuffed animals and the rats in the garage.) Our house is Yuletide decorated to a Griswold level, and almost every night is spoken for with a party, a Christmas movie, or some act of good will, like not throwing food at each other.

We always kick off the season with a Trans-Siberian Orchestra show. Think arena rock with Christmas music. Anyone who doesn’t like TSO should have their children taken away.

Still, fishing goals are never far from my mind. December is a species-sparse time of year in our part of the northern hemisphere, especially in my local area, which I have thoroughly pillaged over the years. I am still always on the lookout in December for some oddball fish I hadn’t thought of, with a keen eye on my thoroughly-OCD fish calendar. (I track the dates of the year on which I have caught new species, and there were only 12 remaining for me to fill, nine of which were in December – 1, 4, 12, and 20-25. Like I said, OCD.)

For December 1, I had been keeping my eye on a particular transplant that has taken up residence in the Bay Area – the bigscale logperch. This darter, likely transported in bait shipments from the Midwest, has set up shop in some random creeks within 50 miles of my home. I had tried and failed a couple of times, but this new spot, a creek in the south bay, was highly recommended by local species genius Vince.

December 1 was a bright, beautiful day in the south bay, which I imagined I would need to chase a darter. Never mind that Vince had warned me at least a dozen times that this particular population lives well off the bank and will not be caught sight fishing. Never mind that he described in detail I would need to cast a small rig out to a secondary dropoff around 30 feet from shore. Despite all of the time he spent with me trying to save me time, I showed up at the place, rigged a tenkara rod, and carefully walked the shoreline fishing like I always do for darters.

That’s my favorite Norwegian Christman sweater.

As Vince had warned me, I got … nothing. This went on for about an hour, and while you are bewildered as to why I didn’t pull out a spinning rod, I was not. I am a creature of bad habits. But after 90 minutes, I was finally getting flustered. The fish were not behaving as I believed they should.

In desperation, I did what I had been told to do all along, and I caught at least a dozen of them in five minutes. Go figure.

There he is, my 8th logperch species.

That’s also darter number 92 and a date scratched off. Only 11 to go. I know, OCD.

The next trip would be in exactly 3 days, because the 4th is three days after the first. Look it up. This would be complicated, because that date fell during our annual Christmas trip to Monterey. There were a few species left for me there, all on the rare side and all requiring the lowest of low tides. But as this is a traditional vacation as a couple, where we tour the aquarium, eat romantic dinners, watch some Christmas specials in the comfort of a Bed and Breakfast, and have the last few arguments about our Christmas letter before we finalize it and send it out to all of you. (She always takes out the fart jokes. That’s why you see so many of them in here.)

I brought fishing gear, as I always do, but it was low odds that I would get a serious shot at anything. On the drive down, I happened to check the tide table, and I was astonished to find one of the lowest tides of the year happened that afternoon. I was considering how to propose the unproposable when Marta unexpectedly made the whole thing easy. “I want to get a facial.” she announced. “They have an appointment at 2:30, and it will take three hours.” It was a Christmas miracle. Never mind that Marta has perfect skin already and that I had to pay – her birthday was coming soon, and I had gotten three hours of fishing in perfect conditions. (In hindsight – Men, always ask what a facial will cost before you volunteer to pay.)

I dropped her off, joyfully drove down to the water, put on my waders, and looked down at absolutely perfect conditions.

On a normal low tide, those women would be knee-deep.

I had two targets – the main one was a high cockscomb, a colorful, eel-like tidepool creature. The alternate was a snubnose sculpin, a deeper-water fish that was much more aspirational. This was a Vince spot, although Zach has fished it more recently, so I texted them both to confirm exact locations.

What followed was one of the greatest millennial text slap-fights I have ever witnessed. To be clear, they are friends and remain friends, but they were talking past each other on some details and men typically let other men know they are wrong in unambiguous terms. “No, you idiot, the spot is on the shore side of the big rock.” “NO, dumbass, it’s to the north of the large boulder.” (That’s the same thing.)

“Ur a moron no offense” is by far my favorite.

I walked out very carefully – damp weeds are very slippery and there are hidden pools that can break an ankle. This was the same place I had gotten a rosy sculpin and a kelp clingfish in prior years, but this time, it was almost dry. I found a few sink-sized pools and began probing ledges and holes with a tenago hook and small fleck of shrimp. I saw fish immediately – some tentative pecks from under an edge – but I couldn’t see the culprit. I kept at it, and finally got a bite that dragged the hook and split shot into a hole. I snapped back and hooked a fish, which vaulted through the air for that eternity it seems to take before grabbing it. With my hands closed around it, I couldn’t see exactly what I had, but I help it tight until I got to a flat, safe area. It was an unexpected black prickleback, a new species, and I had scratched off the 4th.

10 more dates to go.

There were still other species to hunt, so I kept at it. After a couple of repeat sculpins, I got a bite from something that looked eel-like and colorful. It took about ten minutes of working on it, but the fish eventually bit and I yanked it out into my glove hand. I could see in the air it was a high cockscomb – a big score just because they’re gorgeous.

Species two for the day.

The guys, who had since made up, both told me to go looking for snubnose sculpin – there are very few days in the year when the water is low enough to access them on foot. Sunlight was starting to fade, and Marta’s appointment would end soon, but there was no way I was going to miss this. I waded further out, perhaps hip-deep – water that would be well over my head on a normal tide. I saw a few sculpins, but I reasoned that they all couldn’t be the rare one – they all looked to be the same species, with broad saddles and white spots and mottling. I checked my phone. They were ALL snubnose sculpins, and as I lowered the bait, several of them began squabbling over the split shot. I eased the rig up until they saw the bait, and hooked one right away.

Three for the day, less than two hours from my house. Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus.

It had been an unbelievable was to finish an unexpected day. I had four species in December, two dates scratched off, and it was still three weeks to Christmas.

Moonrise over Monterey Bay.

That night, we attended an aquarium event and dinner with one of Marta’s dearest friends, Bianca, and her husband Kevin. Bianca was a highly ranked power lifter for years, and Kevin can bench press a car.

The four species would have been good enough, because those three weeks were jammed full of Christmas movies and overeating.

Our main Christmas party, a dinner that started in 2000 as a staff event that has grown to include co-workers, hockey teammates, high school buddies, kindred fisherman, and Spellman.

But just a few days before Christmas, Santa smiled on me again. We had one day – the 22nd – that was curiously without plans, and, as it turned out, one of her consulting clients had an emergency that day and she had to go to San Diego. I figured this was a sign from God and I called Vince to consult on what might be biting. We settled on the sharpnose sculpin, which he felt would bite readily. The drawback – it was a six-hour drive north in California to a place called “Sue-meg State Park.” Guest parking is far from the fishing and restricted to daylight hours, so the trick is to get a campsite, which is right by the access. So I did – and don’t worry, I had no intent of camping. There was a Hyatt in nearby Eureka.

The drive was miserable – rain until I reached the redwoods, but the forecast held true and it cleared up as I got within a couple of hours of the spot. I stuffed myself with about $30 worth of Burger King and headed to my destination with a couple of hours to spare before sunset. The scenery there was marvelous and got even more so, and as I finally turned off the freeway, the place looked very, very familiar. I processed it for a moment, and as the whole coastline came into view, it hit me – this was Patrick’s Point, scene of unfortunate events in 1982. It had been renamed to the original Yurok Indian name, but to me it will always be Patrick’s Point.

Still a bit dazed by the coincidence, I checked in with the ranger and got my campsite and a map. I wound my way through the forest lanes – they really have done a great job keeping this place beautiful – and pulled up to campsite 98.

Yes, I think my license plate is perfectly ok.

Just as I stepped out of my car, my mind jumped back 43 years and compared notes. Not only was it the same park, it was the EXACT SAME CAMPSITE. I could almost hear Cindy yelling “You moron! Normal people do not behave this way!” And I smiled. (By the way, Cindy became a highly-regarded high school science teacher in a nearby town, now happily retired, and yes, I did find her and apologize, but she wonders what Marta could be thinking.)

Back in the present day, I put on my waders and prepared to go down what I remember as a gentle slope to the tidepools. The overlook was breathtaking, and I regretted not bringing my surf rods, as it looked like there was another record redtail nearby.

That beach has to loaded with big perch.

The walk was longer and steeper than I remembered. The downhill part was not too brutal, but I knew I would be coming back up those same stairs in a few hours, and wondered how it would go. The tidepools were just a couple of hundred yards south.

The pools were perfect – not too deep or surgy, perfectly clear, and loaded with fish.

The tide was still bottoming out, so I worked my way to the deeper edges and started looking. I probably strayed too deep, because I was dreaming of a snailfish. I caught dozens of fish, but none of the right one.

Although this mini buffalo sculpin was really cool.

I finally fell back on actually following Vince and Zach’s advice and looking at some very specific structure – shallower pools with plenty of sand.

Like this one.

It took a while to cover 200 feet back to where I should have started – be careful in tidepools, folks – but as soon as I saw the first smaller pool, it was loaded with the right fish. I caught three or four just to make sure, and my mission was successful.

Nine dates to go. Say it with me – OCD.

I stuck around for an hour or two looking for snailfish, but they would have to wait for another holiday low tide another year. I wasn’t looking forward to climbing back up the hill, but the real problem was finding the path on the dark. People – ALWAYS find or leave a mark for a crucial exit. I eventually found it, and let me tell you, half a mile of steep cliff in waders was not my idea of a good time. Think blisters. Think chafing. But think thrilled with the catch, and smiled to myself even as I got to my burger in the Hyatt restaurant. That was five species for December, taking me to 2425. It had been a hell of a year, but at this stage, aren’t they all?

I returned home to a flurry of activity to get ready for our Christmas Eve and Christmas gatherings.

Christmas Eve would not be Christmas Eve without our friends Michael, Megan, Cooper, and Buckley the dog. Buckley is a purebreed King Charles Barkley Bacon Hound.

It is truly the most wonderful time of the year, especially when we replay “Scrooged” for visitors.

A happy holiday to each any every one of you, even Cousin Chuck.

Steve

 

 


Leave a Reply

Categories